I'll resolve this using the same system as https://manifold.markets/AmmonLam/what-is-the-best-animal-strength-in
Forecasting skill includes performance on Manifold and on other platforms. Consistent accuracy and correct contrarian takes both highly valued.
Fun and nice: do they generally make Manifold a pleasant and interesting place to hang out
Insider trading: Do they have historic examples of cool or audacious insider trades? Can they insider trade this market somehow?
Former/inactive users are allowed but you might need to tell me about them
Update 2026-02-27 (PST) (AI summary of creator comment): Insider trading is considered a positive attribute for the purposes of evaluating candidates in this market.
Update 2026-02-27 (PST) (AI summary of creator comment): Users with the name "Pat" receive bonus points on the insider trading criterion when evaluating candidates.
Update 2026-02-27 (PST) (AI summary of creator comment): "Other" will not be a valid answer after market close. Only the top 10 concrete answers will be evaluated for resolution.
Update 2026-03-01 (PST) (AI summary of creator comment): Final 10 candidates being evaluated for resolution:
Bayesian
SemioticRivalry
Joshua
Eliza
@jim
bens
ziddletwix
Quroe
Brad
strutheo
Only these 10 concrete answers will be considered. Traders are encouraged to provide specific feats (concrete examples of things these users have done) in the three categories (Forecasting skill, Fun and Nice, Insider Trading) to inform the resolution decision.
People are also trading
I guess I'm compelled to provide evidence to support my own case:
Forecasting Skill:
I'm currently 28th all time on the Manifold leaderboard, which puts me in 6th out of the 10 finalists (crazy competition). However, I'm also the 6th all-time winningest forecaster on Metaculus, despite only forecasting seriously on that platform for about 1.5 years:

On top of this, you can track another metric of my forecasting performance on my grobbles-flobbling market. I've been cited as a "prediction markets expert" in the Atlantic as well, for what it's worth.
Fun and Nice:
I organized the first ManifestX conference for fun! I'm very receptive to hijinks and I run a lot of "fun" markets. I also have a blog post I'm finishing up that should be out soon on why prediction markets need more Whimsy. Perhaps some of you will find it fun. I've met 6 out of the other 9 finalists, and have had fun with several of them, I believe. Also, this is fun: https://www.benshindel.com/manifest
Insider Trading:
I write the Manifold newsletter and have friends in high places in the Ukrainian, Israeli, and United State governments, so I have a high capacity for insider trading which I refrain from utilizing due to moral and ethical considerations. However, in legal and permissible cases on Manifold, a play-money platform, I have been known to insider trade.
@bens not gonna lie "I could totally insider trade but I choose not to" is probably harming your scoring on this axis
@draaglom Us mere mortals do not have the powers of the gods. I don't think we can unrank unless the AI detects the question worthy of the special, official "unranked" tag during creation. The tag you have now is an imposter.
@JustCallMeKeith He's pretty cool if you meet him in real life. He knew how to play up the audience too when I had him as a contestant on my game show at Manifest 2025.
@draaglom can you re-open betting for a couple days on the final 10? Or was the intention to close before they were announced?
OK @traders, the final 10 are:
- Bayesian
- SemioticRivalry
- Joshua
- Eliza
- @jim
- bens
- ziddletwix
- Quroe
- Brad
- strutheo
Please do reply in thread with specific relevant Feats these users have achieved in any of the three categories for consideration. Particularly helpful are instances of Fun and Nice and Insider Trading, as these might not be visible to me by default if I've not interacted with you a lot.
By feats I mean specific things they've done - it's kinda tough for me to work with an "I endorse foo" however true and well meant it is.
Lastly, I hope this goes without saying, but you are all (including everyone who didn't make the top 10) a good bunch and it'll be tough to rank everyone. No hard feelings with the final list, it's just a bit of fun π
@draaglom Running a prediction market game show at Manifest 2025 was fun. Is that a feat? /Quroe/nash-pit-manifest-2025-what-choice
I would also like to present to the court that I was asked to be the executor to the conclusion to another high stakes Manifold game, FOLDED. /Quroe/the-folded-accords-season-1
jim:
Forecasting
Predicted LK-99 was real
Fun and or Nice
Bailed out some of Manifold's best-loved users incl. Predictor and Gigacuking
Insider Trading
Traveled to London to get alpha on a potato eating market
